PNG to ICO downloaded-file lab
PNG to ICO: Downloads From 9 Converter Sites
In a four-PNG test, seven sites produced complete ICO matrices, two produced one verified result each, and one produced no verifiable file. Their saved outputs varied in layers, geometry, encoding, and alpha. Inspect the downloaded ICO rather than judging the page label.
Convert a PNG to ICOSeven sites completed the four-PNG matrix: ConvertICO.com, PNGtoICO.com, TheCalcu, Toolz.dev, PNGConvert.net, EditItAll, and Caspian Office. ConvertICO.com returned six uncompressed DIB layers in every 370,070-byte file; PNGtoICO.com returned nine in every 381,038-byte file. TheCalcu, Toolz.dev, and PNGConvert.net returned four PNG-compressed layers, while Caspian Office returned three. EditItAll returned one layer per file, including a 96 × 256 layer for the tall source. CanDoYa and ConvertICO.net have one verified source sample each; Go Tools has no locally verified download. The table and CSV use downloaded files, not page labels.
Measured 26 September 2026 from four local inputs: square-art.png (320 × 320, 1,401 bytes), narrow-art.png (120 × 320, 989 bytes), tiny-art.png (24 × 24, 168 bytes), and fully-transparent.png (320 × 320, 477 bytes). A separate 512 × 512 transparent PNG was unavailable and was not recreated. Seven sites have full four-input matrices; CanDoYa and ConvertICO.net have one-source results; Go Tools is excluded from measurements because no output file was verified. Exact SHA-256 values and hash-equality matches are in the project ammo list.
Seven complete matrices show different output conventions
ConvertICO.com produced six DIB32 BI_RGB uncompressed frames (16, 32, 48, 64, 128, and 256 pixels) in every file; each was 370,070 bytes. PNGtoICO.com produced nine uncompressed frames (16, 20, 24, 32, 40, 48, 64, 128, and 256 pixels); each file was 381,038 bytes. Their file lengths stayed constant across the four shapes because these decoded DIB payloads occupied fixed sizes.
TheCalcu, Toolz.dev, and PNGConvert.net each returned PNG/DEFLATE frames at 16, 32, 48, and 256 pixels, but their file lengths varied with the source. Caspian Office returned only 16, 32, and 48 pixel layers. EditItAll returned one layer per input: the tall image became a 96 × 256 DIB32 frame, while the other three were single PNG frames. These are behaviors of these downloaded outputs and settings only.
The tall source makes the geometry differences visible in decoded pixels
For the 120 × 320 narrow-art input, the DIB outputs from ConvertICO.com and PNGtoICO.com had 16,048 alpha-positive pixels in the 256 × 256 frame and 92 in the 16 × 16 frame. TheCalcu and Toolz.dev had 42,648 and 168 respectively at those sizes; their partially transparent 16 × 16 pixels were 116 and 88. PNGConvert.net had 16,048 alpha-positive pixels at 256 × 256. Caspian Office’s frames were 16, 32, and 48 square; EditItAll instead emitted a 96 × 256 frame with 16,052 alpha-positive pixels.
Alpha counts report decoded pixel values; they are not a visual-quality score and do not explain why each site chose its geometry. Use the linked originals and per-frame counts to inspect the same input and size.
The fully transparent source stayed transparent in every complete matrix
For the seven sites with four verified files, every decoded frame made from fully-transparent.png had zero pixels with alpha above zero. The 256 × 256 DIB payloads at ConvertICO.com and PNGtoICO.com were each 270,376 bytes despite containing no visible pixels. PNG-compressed outputs were much smaller, but exact sizes differed by site.
This tests a fully clear image only. It does not establish how any of these sites handles partially transparent edges in other artwork.
Three pairs of downloads had identical SHA-256 values
The one retrieved CanDoYa square-art file matches TheCalcu square-art byte for byte. TheCalcu and Toolz.dev also produced matching bytes for tiny-art and fully-transparent. Full hashes are retained in the ammo-list CSV alongside each file path and the frame-by-frame values. These matches do not establish shared ownership, infrastructure, or code.
Coverage limits and downloadable evidence
The complete four-image matrices cover ConvertICO.com, PNGtoICO.com, TheCalcu, Toolz.dev, PNGConvert.net, EditItAll, and Caspian Office. CanDoYa yielded one square-art output. ConvertICO.net yielded one square-art favicon plus separate 16, 32, and 48 pixel ICOs. Go Tools produced no locally verifiable output, so it has no measurement row. The separate 512 × 512 transparent source was unavailable and was not substituted.
The measurement CSV provides all 131 frame rows from the 30 primary matrix ICOs. The ammo list retains the output hashes and all 33 downloaded-file records, including ConvertICO.net’s three separate single-size files. The original ICO files and four source PNGs are linked below.
For fitting a rectangular image without distortion, see the [fitting a rectangular image without distortion](png-to-ico-rectangle-without-distortion).
Downloaded-file matrix
Each row below is a locally saved ICO output. The linked CSV has one row per frame, including exact payload bytes and decoded alpha counts. The project ammo list records full SHA-256 hashes for each saved file.
| Converter | Source PNG | ICO bytes | Frames and dimensions | Payload encoding and compression |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ConvertICO.com | square-art.png (320 × 320) | 370,070 | 6: 256 × 256, 128 × 128, 64 × 64, 48 × 48, 32 × 32, 16 × 16 | DIB32, BI_RGB (uncompressed) |
| ConvertICO.com | narrow-art.png (120 × 320) | 370,070 | 6: 256 × 256, 128 × 128, 64 × 64, 48 × 48, 32 × 32, 16 × 16 | DIB32, BI_RGB (uncompressed) |
| ConvertICO.com | tiny-art.png (24 × 24) | 370,070 | 6: 256 × 256, 128 × 128, 64 × 64, 48 × 48, 32 × 32, 16 × 16 | DIB32, BI_RGB (uncompressed) |
| ConvertICO.com | fully-transparent.png (320 × 320) | 370,070 | 6: 256 × 256, 128 × 128, 64 × 64, 48 × 48, 32 × 32, 16 × 16 | DIB32, BI_RGB (uncompressed) |
| PNGtoICO.com | square-art.png (320 × 320) | 381,038 | 9: 256 × 256, 128 × 128, 64 × 64, 48 × 48, 40 × 40, 32 × 32, 24 × 24, 20 × 20, 16 × 16 | DIB32, BI_RGB (uncompressed) |
| PNGtoICO.com | narrow-art.png (120 × 320) | 381,038 | 9: 256 × 256, 128 × 128, 64 × 64, 48 × 48, 40 × 40, 32 × 32, 24 × 24, 20 × 20, 16 × 16 | DIB32, BI_RGB (uncompressed) |
| PNGtoICO.com | tiny-art.png (24 × 24) | 381,038 | 9: 256 × 256, 128 × 128, 64 × 64, 48 × 48, 40 × 40, 32 × 32, 24 × 24, 20 × 20, 16 × 16 | DIB32, BI_RGB (uncompressed) |
| PNGtoICO.com | fully-transparent.png (320 × 320) | 381,038 | 9: 256 × 256, 128 × 128, 64 × 64, 48 × 48, 40 × 40, 32 × 32, 24 × 24, 20 × 20, 16 × 16 | DIB32, BI_RGB (uncompressed) |
| TheCalcu.com | square-art.png (320 × 320) | 5,853 | 4: 16 × 16, 32 × 32, 48 × 48, 256 × 256 | PNG, PNG (DEFLATE) |
| TheCalcu.com | narrow-art.png (120 × 320) | 5,652 | 4: 16 × 16, 32 × 32, 48 × 48, 256 × 256 | PNG, PNG (DEFLATE) |
| TheCalcu.com | tiny-art.png (24 × 24) | 12,489 | 4: 16 × 16, 32 × 32, 48 × 48, 256 × 256 | PNG, PNG (DEFLATE) |
| TheCalcu.com | fully-transparent.png (320 × 320) | 2,900 | 4: 16 × 16, 32 × 32, 48 × 48, 256 × 256 | PNG, PNG (DEFLATE) |
| Toolz.dev | square-art.png (320 × 320) | 5,002 | 4: 16 × 16, 32 × 32, 48 × 48, 256 × 256 | PNG, PNG (DEFLATE) |
| Toolz.dev | narrow-art.png (120 × 320) | 5,422 | 4: 16 × 16, 32 × 32, 48 × 48, 256 × 256 | PNG, PNG (DEFLATE) |
| Toolz.dev | tiny-art.png (24 × 24) | 12,489 | 4: 16 × 16, 32 × 32, 48 × 48, 256 × 256 | PNG, PNG (DEFLATE) |
| Toolz.dev | fully-transparent.png (320 × 320) | 2,900 | 4: 16 × 16, 32 × 32, 48 × 48, 256 × 256 | PNG, PNG (DEFLATE) |
| PNGConvert.net | square-art.png (320 × 320) | 5,841 | 4: 256 × 256, 48 × 48, 32 × 32, 16 × 16 | PNG, PNG (DEFLATE) |
| PNGConvert.net | narrow-art.png (120 × 320) | 4,637 | 4: 256 × 256, 48 × 48, 32 × 32, 16 × 16 | PNG, PNG (DEFLATE) |
| PNGConvert.net | tiny-art.png (24 × 24) | 19,708 | 4: 256 × 256, 48 × 48, 32 × 32, 16 × 16 | PNG, PNG (DEFLATE) |
| PNGConvert.net | fully-transparent.png (320 × 320) | 2,900 | 4: 256 × 256, 48 × 48, 32 × 32, 16 × 16 | PNG, PNG (DEFLATE) |
| EditItAll | square-art.png (320 × 320) | 2,963 | 1: 256 × 256 | PNG, PNG (DEFLATE) |
| EditItAll | narrow-art.png (120 × 320) | 101,438 | 1: 96 × 256 | DIB32, BI_RGB (uncompressed) |
| EditItAll | tiny-art.png (24 × 24) | 2,462 | 1: 24 × 24 | DIB32, BI_RGB (uncompressed) |
| EditItAll | fully-transparent.png (320 × 320) | 356 | 1: 256 × 256 | PNG, PNG (DEFLATE) |
| Caspian Office | square-art.png (320 × 320) | 1,824 | 3: 16 × 16, 32 × 32, 48 × 48 | PNG, PNG (DEFLATE) |
| Caspian Office | narrow-art.png (120 × 320) | 1,255 | 3: 16 × 16, 32 × 32, 48 × 48 | PNG, PNG (DEFLATE) |
| Caspian Office | tiny-art.png (24 × 24) | 1,582 | 3: 16 × 16, 32 × 32, 48 × 48 | PNG, PNG (DEFLATE) |
| Caspian Office | fully-transparent.png (320 × 320) | 520 | 3: 16 × 16, 32 × 32, 48 × 48 | PNG, PNG (DEFLATE) |
| CanDoYa | square-art.png (320 × 320) | 5,853 | 4: 16 × 16, 32 × 32, 48 × 48, 256 × 256 | PNG, PNG (DEFLATE) |
| ConvertICO.net | square-art.png (320 × 320) | 1,011 | 3: 16 × 16, 32 × 32, 48 × 48 | PNG, PNG (DEFLATE) |
| ConvertICO.net (separate icon file) | square-art.png (320 × 320) | 260 | 1: 16 × 16 | PNG, PNG/DEFLATE |
| ConvertICO.net (separate icon file) | square-art.png (320 × 320) | 319 | 1: 32 × 32 | PNG, PNG/DEFLATE |
| ConvertICO.net (separate icon file) | square-art.png (320 × 320) | 444 | 1: 48 × 48 | PNG, PNG/DEFLATE |
Three SHA-256-equal output pairs were found: CanDoYa square-art and TheCalcu square-art; TheCalcu and Toolz.dev tiny-art; and TheCalcu and Toolz.dev fully-transparent. Identical bytes do not establish shared code or ownership. ConvertICO.net’s table includes the downloaded multi-size favicon plus its three separate single-size ICO files.
- Full frame-by-frame measurements CSV
- ConvertICO.com: square-art.ico (370,070 bytes; SHA-256 8032E08DABA9… )
- ConvertICO.com: narrow-art.ico (370,070 bytes; SHA-256 C485BF530522… )
- ConvertICO.com: tiny-art.ico (370,070 bytes; SHA-256 AA829776DF7E… )
- ConvertICO.com: fully-transparent.ico (370,070 bytes; SHA-256 63105E53FD59… )
- PNGtoICO.com: square-art.ico (381,038 bytes; SHA-256 A6FB7CD71C06… )
- PNGtoICO.com: narrow-art.ico (381,038 bytes; SHA-256 6B8736663040… )
- PNGtoICO.com: tiny-art.ico (381,038 bytes; SHA-256 A334E299748F… )
- PNGtoICO.com: fully-transparent.ico (381,038 bytes; SHA-256 12FB67B828C3… )
- TheCalcu.com: square-art.ico (5,853 bytes; SHA-256 5BB98F162F8F… )
- TheCalcu.com: narrow-art.ico (5,652 bytes; SHA-256 7B2DBDBBF7A8… )
- TheCalcu.com: tiny-art.ico (12,489 bytes; SHA-256 C5E5A3F43E13… )
- TheCalcu.com: fully-transparent.ico (2,900 bytes; SHA-256 64165E9BFCA5… )
- Toolz.dev: square-art.ico (5,002 bytes; SHA-256 89463ABD63C6… )
- Toolz.dev: narrow-art.ico (5,422 bytes; SHA-256 830482798000… )
- Toolz.dev: tiny-art.ico (12,489 bytes; SHA-256 C5E5A3F43E13… )
- Toolz.dev: fully-transparent.ico (2,900 bytes; SHA-256 64165E9BFCA5… )
- PNGConvert.net: square-art.ico (5,841 bytes; SHA-256 CD17C9D6CAD9… )
- PNGConvert.net: narrow-art.ico (4,637 bytes; SHA-256 BA835AEB36E7… )
- PNGConvert.net: tiny-art.ico (19,708 bytes; SHA-256 29590D7D974B… )
- PNGConvert.net: fully-transparent.ico (2,900 bytes; SHA-256 7E4B5FD841B9… )
- EditItAll: square-art.ico (2,963 bytes; SHA-256 413E7428EF14… )
- EditItAll: narrow-art.ico (101,438 bytes; SHA-256 3FED034FC549… )
- EditItAll: tiny-art.ico (2,462 bytes; SHA-256 9DF668F214D5… )
- EditItAll: fully-transparent.ico (356 bytes; SHA-256 B824AE4F2C3F… )
- Caspian Office: square-art.ico (1,824 bytes; SHA-256 634E77408225… )
- Caspian Office: narrow-art.ico (1,255 bytes; SHA-256 2BF551687388… )
- Caspian Office: tiny-art.ico (1,582 bytes; SHA-256 E11D41E210F1… )
- Caspian Office: fully-transparent.ico (520 bytes; SHA-256 8A3828784702… )
- CanDoYa: square-art.ico (5,853 bytes; SHA-256 5BB98F162F8F… )
- ConvertICO.net: favicon.ico (1,011 bytes; SHA-256 0F53A06F7C63… )
- ConvertICO.net: icon-16x16.ico (260 bytes; SHA-256 C0B9C87B149A… )
- ConvertICO.net: icon-32x32.ico (319 bytes; SHA-256 B97A2C3F900A… )
- ConvertICO.net: icon-48x48.ico (444 bytes; SHA-256 ABD1B4229F43… )
- Source PNG: square-art.png
- Source PNG: narrow-art.png
- Source PNG: tiny-art.png
- Source PNG: fully-transparent.png
What the downloaded ICO files contain
- 01Use the same four local PNGs
The inputs were square artwork, a tall 120 × 320 image, a 24 × 24 image, and a fully transparent 320 × 320 image. The original files are linked below.
- 02Decode each downloaded ICO
Layer dimensions and payload lengths came from the downloaded ICO directory. PNG payloads were decoded; DIB dimensions, compression fields, and alpha bytes were read from the bitmap data. Page labels were not used as measurements.
- 03Compare matching source and layer sizes
A site’s file size, frame count, encoding, layer geometry, and alpha counts are listed separately. Different frame sets should not be compared as if total bytes represented the same set of images.
FAQ
Questions about this downloaded-file audit
How many sites completed all four test images?
Seven of the ten named converters returned four locally verified ICO downloads each. CanDoYa and ConvertICO.net have one source sample each; no Go Tools output was verified.
Does a higher alpha-positive pixel count mean a better icon?
No. It counts pixels with alpha above zero in a decoded frame. It does not measure recognizability, edge quality, or whether the geometry is desirable.
Was a separate 512 × 512 transparent PNG included?
No. That original input was not available in the project or Downloads folder, and an existing ICO is not a substitute for the PNG.
Do matching SHA-256 values prove two sites share a backend?
No. They establish that the particular downloaded files are byte-identical. They do not identify how either site produced them.